The Case That Could Change Licensing Law in America
Case Overview
This lawsuit alleges that the NY Department of Health (DOH) unlawfully revoked radiography licenses from graduates of an accredited university—without due process—violating state procedure, constitutional law, and basic fairness.
What's at Stake?
Hundreds of radiologic technologists—many Black, Brown, and immigrant professionals—had their licenses revoked or suspended. These licenses are legally considered property under the 14th Amendment. Seizing them without a hearing or legal process is unconstitutional.
Timeline of Events
Why This Case Matters
✅ JPU's Accreditation: Fully accredited by ACCSC, recognized by the U.S. Department of Education and ARRT.
✅ Licensing Law: NY regulations allow graduates from JRCERT OR other accrediting bodies—the law is clear.
❌ Due Process Violation: Licenses revoked without hearings = 14th Amendment violation.
❌ SAPA Violation: DOH created a new rule without public input or formal regulation.
Legal Breakdown
- • Unpromulgated Rule (SAPA Violation)
- • Arbitrary & Capricious Action
- • Due Process Violation (Goldberg v. Kelly precedent)
- • Equal Protection / Discrimination
- • Conflicting agency guidance (NYSED vs DOH)
⏱️ Legal Odds & Timeline
| ⚖️ Legal Step | 📈 Probability | 🗓️ Time Frame |
|---|---|---|
| TRO (Emergency Injunction) | 90–95% | 1–3 weeks |
| Preliminary Injunction | 75–85% | 2–6 months |
| Final Victory in Court | 60–75% | 6–18 months |
| Settlement (out of court) | 70% | Within 3–6 months |
🛠️ Students likely back to work within weeks if TRO is granted.
Potential Financial Payouts
If a federal civil rights suit under §1983 follows:
Lost wages: $5,000–$35,000+
Emotional distress: $10,000–$50,000
Punitive damages (select cases): $25,000–$100,000
200+ affected graduates
Estimated class total damages: $5 million–$20 million+
What You Can Do
📢 Share this case to spread awareness
The case between John Patrick University (JPU) and the New York Department of Health represents a classic example of government agencies changing the rules mid-game and potentially violating constitutional rights in the process. This lawsuit has significant implications not just for JPU students, but for how government agencies can alter licensing requirements without proper legal procedures.